Cellier's Dorothy (1886)

   

How did this 1886 light opera manage to become so popular that its box office profits were sufficient to build a new London theatre, The Lyric of Shaftesbury Avenue? When launched at the Gaiety Theatre the comedy opera initially received only a lukewarm reception and gave little indication of any long-standing success.  

A wily accountant and theatre manager, Henry Leslie bought the musical's rights and costumes at low cost and relaunched the piece at the Prince of Wales Theatre with Ben Davies as Wilder, Hayden Coffin as Sherwood and Furneaux Cook as Bantam. Marie Tempest later replaced Marion Hood in the title role. The recipe of this excellent cast soon brought good box office receipts and helped it achieve a successful 931 performances and see off the Mikado's 672 and Ruddigore's 288 performances during its run. We need to further understand the secret for this.  

The music of Dorothy contains good variety in its construction and includes both dances and a ballet. The critics referred to the show as 'pretty', 'graceful', and 'charming'. Cellier's orchestration is certainly bright, rich and varied, and he skillfully links sections within a number to maintain momentum. To aid diction, the accompaniment to verses is light as with Sullivan and carries echoes of the music hall, then in vogue, in the chorus numbers. We find that the chorus parts are well scored with up to five parts of harmony, as befitting a composer schooled at the Chapel Royal.

      

Cellier, Leslie, Stephenson

Stephenson's book has weaknesses but they are covered by the strong characters of Wilder, Sherwood, Dorothy and Lydia who hold interest with their amorous and mischievous behaviour. Comedy is introduced by a scruffy Sheriff's officer (Lurcher) in his wooing to an upper crust Mrs. Privett (her speech affliction complementing his dropped aitches). Their interaction with Squire Bantam leads to effectively embarrassing moments with double-entendres adding much amusement. Such larger than life characters could have been taken out of a Victorian Drury Lane pantomime. During the early weeks of the run the script was tightened and much improved to overcome the concerns of the first night critics.  

For Cellier's revision, he chose librettist B C Stephenson who had written Sullivan's The Zoo in 1875 (under the pen name, Bolton Rowe). For Dorothy, Stephenson was handicapped by needing to fit new lyrics to Cellier's existing music. This is never an easy task as W S Gilbert once found out. It can explain why some of Dorothy's lyrics seem uninspired in construction. Where songs were freshly composed, Stephenson fairs better. He provides well written and believable dialogue throughout. An interpolated number for Hayden Coffin (as Sherwood) was "Queen of my Heart". This was an early Cellier & Stephenson romance known as "Old Dreams", and given new words. It was introduced after the first night and became one of Dorothy's hit songs that became widely known from first a Polyphon disc (1890s), then on a pianola roll of Dorothy selections of c.1905, then from 78 records of Beka Grand (c.1915) Zonophone (1931) and by George Baker on Decca, then heard with full orchestra for the first time c.1933.

 The fact that this musical became such a success seems more amazing when one finds that Cellier originally composed its music for an earlier operetta, Nell Gwynne (1876). When Nell Gwynne was originally staged in Manchester at the Princes Theatre it was deemed a failure when it achieved only 24 performances. The composer blamed the librettist, H. B. Farnie, and the librettist blamed the composer. Although some of the songs had been published they decided to buy back their material from the publisher Metzler and go their separate ways and not to risk taking it to London.   

 

Marie Tempest

The book and music was remodelled with different partners. Both of the revised shows faired better, but Nell Gwynne only achieved 86 performances while Cellier's Dorothy played and played. For Cellier's revision, he chose librettist B C Stephenson who had written Sullivan's The Zoo in 1875 (under the pen name, Bolton Rowe).

For Dorothy, Stephenson was handicapped by needing to fit new lyrics to Cellier's existing music. This is never an easy task as W S Gilbert once found out. It can explain why some of Dorothy's lyrics seem uninspired in construction. Where songs were freshly composed, Stephenson fairs better. He provides well written and believable dialogue throughout. An interpolated number for Hayden Coffin (as Sherwood) was "Queen of my Heart". This was an early Cellier & Stephenson romance known as "Old Dreams", and given new words. It was introduced after the first night and became one of Dorothy's hit songs that became widely known from first a Polyphon disc (1890s), then on a pianola roll of Dorothy selections of c.1905, then from 78 records of Beka Grand (c.1915) Zonophone (1931) and by George Baker on Decca, then heard with full orchestra for the first time c.1933.

One is conscious of a rustic, idyllic innocence in the melodies and rhythms that conjure up thoughts of a 'Constable' backdrop such as could be found sixteen years later in Edward German's light rustic opera, Merrie England. Selections from the show became a feature of the Henry Wood London Promenade Concerts in 1895 and the following year. The comic opera toured on three continents before becoming popular with amateur operatic societies round the world.